Let's analyze the claims made in the text for factual accuracy: Claim about Quran 20.85 and the Samaritan woman: Verification: The verse in question, Quran 20:85, mentions a "Samaritan" (in Arabic, "…
Original video: https://www.tiktok.com/@jesus.and.whatnot/video/7604590456940301581
Fact checked on: March 28, 2026
Fact Check Analysis
Let's analyze the claims made in the text for factual accuracy:
-
Claim about Quran 20.85 and the Samaritan woman:
- Verification: The verse in question, Quran 20:85, mentions a "Samaritan" (in Arabic, "As-Samiri") but does not refer to a Samaritan woman. The term "Samaritan" in this context does not necessarily refer to the historical Samaritan people known from later periods. Islamic scholars often interpret "As-Samiri" as a specific individual, not necessarily linked to the Samaritan ethnic group. Therefore, the claim that this is a historical contradiction is based on a misunderstanding of the text.
-
Claim about Allah forgiving the worship of other gods (Quran 4.48 vs. 4.153):
- Verification: Quran 4:48 states that Allah does not forgive associating partners with Him (shirk) if one dies in that state, but He may forgive other sins. Quran 4:153 does not directly address the forgiveness of shirk but rather discusses the forgiveness of the Children of Israel after they worshipped the calf, emphasizing Allah's mercy. The context and interpretation are crucial here, and many scholars argue that these verses do not directly contradict each other when understood within their contexts.
-
Claim about the creation timeline (Quran 10.3 vs. 41.9-12):
- Verification: Quran 10:3 mentions that Allah created the heavens and the earth in six days. Quran 41:9-12 describes the creation process in more detail, which some interpret as totaling eight days. However, many Islamic scholars explain that the four days mentioned in 41:10 include the two days mentioned in 41:9, thus maintaining a total of six days. This is a matter of interpretation rather than a clear contradiction.
-
Claim about disbelievers being blind (Quran 21.24 vs. 16.76):
- Verification: Quran 21:24 does not mention disbelievers being blind on the Day of Resurrection. It is likely a reference to Quran 20:124-125, which mentions that those who turn away from Allah's message will be resurrected blind. Quran 16:76 does not discuss the Day of Resurrection but uses a metaphor about partners. The claim seems to misinterpret or misquote the verses.
- Claim about dealing justly with multiple wives (Quran 4.3 vs. 4.129):
- Verification: Quran 4:3 allows men to marry up to four wives if they can deal justly with them. Quran 4:129 acknowledges the difficulty of being entirely just, especially in matters of the heart, but advises not to neglect one wife completely. These verses highlight the challenges of fairness rather than presenting a direct contradiction.
In summary, the claims of contradictions often arise from misinterpretations or lack of context. The verses cited do not present clear contradictions when understood within their broader textual and historical contexts.
Video transcript
I will leave Islam right now if one person finds me a contradiction in this book. Challenge accepted, but I'm not stopping at just one contradiction. I'm going to give you five. Let's get started. The first contradiction comes from Quran 20.85, where we read that Moses was talking to a Samaritan woman. That is historically impossible because Moses was alive around 1200 BC, while the Samaritan people wouldn't even exist until 500 years later in 720 BC. The second contradiction comes from the question, can Allah forgive worshiping other gods? Here we read in Quran 4.48 that he cannot forgive people who worship other gods. But then right in Quran 4.153, we read, yes, he can forgive people who worship other gods. The third contradiction is found in Quran 10.3, where we read that it took six days for Allah to create the heavens and the earth. But then in Quran 41.9-12, we read that it took Allah two days to create the earth, four more days to bless it, and then two more days to ordain the seven heavens, which is eight days in total, not six. The next contradiction comes from Quran 21.24, where we read that disbelievers will be blind on the day of resurrection. But then in Quran 16.76, we read that they will see their partners. How can they see partners if they are blind? Finally, Quran 4.3 tells us that it is possible to deal justly with multiple wives. But then Quran 4.129 tells us, no, it is not possible. I cannot wait to see you leave Islam. I will tag you in this video to make sure that you see it and all of the contradictions that your lying prophet told. God bless.